Subway Secret Menu


Have you ever heard of the Subway Secret Menu? Are you curious about what hidden gems might be lurking behind the counter at your favorite sandwich shop?

The Subway Secret Menu is a treasure trove of delicious combinations and customizations that aren’t listed on the regular menu.

These off-menu items are like a secret handshake among Subway enthusiasts, offering unique flavors and textures that’ll take your sandwich game to the next level.

Whether you’re a long-time Subway fan or just looking to spice up your lunch routine, exploring the underground option at Subway menu can be an exciting culinary adventure.

Subway Secret Menu

From protein-packed powerhouses to indulgent comfort food creations, there’s something for everyone on this hush-hush menu.

In this article, we’ll unveil some of the most popular secret menu items, explain how to order them, and share tips on creating your own custom masterpieces. Get ready to become a Subway insider and impress your friends with your sandwich savvy!

What is the Subway Secret Menu?

Before we sink our teeth into the juicy details, let’s clarify what we mean by a “secret menu.” It’s not some clandestine list hidden in the back room of your local Subway.

Instead, it’s a collection of unofficial sandwich combinations and customizations that clever customers and creative employees have concocted over the years.

Subway Secret Menu

Subway Secret Menu

The Pizza Sub

The Pizza Sub tops the list as the most beloved secret menu item. This mouthwatering creation transforms your Subway experience into a pizza parlor delight. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Base: Italian Herbs and Cheese bread
  • Toppings: Marinara sauce, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese
  • Pro tip: Ask for it toasted to get that authentic pizza feel

The Carnivore

Meat lovers, rejoice! The Carnivore is a protein-packed powerhouse that combines multiple meat options in one sub. Here’s how to order:

  • Base: Your choice of bread
  • Meats: Ham, turkey, roast beef, and bacon
  • Pro tip: Add some veggies for balance and crunch

The Wing Effect

Craving the flavors of buffalo wings? The Wing Effect brings that spicy, tangy goodness to your Subway sandwich:

  • Base: Italian bread
  • Protein: Chicken strips
  • Sauce: Buffalo sauce and ranch dressing
  • Extras: Add lettuce and tomatoes for freshness

The Old Cut

While not a sandwich itself, The Old Cut is a popular secret menu technique that changes how your sub is prepared:

  • Ask for your bread to be cut in a V-shape from the top
  • This method allows for more fillings and better ingredient distribution
  • Pro tip: Works great with saucy subs like meatball marinara

The Garlic Bread Sub

Transform any Subway sandwich into a Garlic Bread Sub with this simple hack:

  • Choose your regular sandwich
  • Ask for garlic butter or garlic aioli to be spread on the bread
  • Request the sub to be toasted
  • Result: A garlicky, aromatic twist on your favorite Subway creation

The Feast

Can’t decide which meats to choose? Get them all with The Feast! This monster sandwich includes every available meat option, creating a tower of deliciousness that’s not for the faint of heart.

The Big Philly Cheesesteak

Take the classic Philly Cheesesteak and supersize it. Ask for extra steak, double cheese, and all your favorite veggies. It’s a taste of Philadelphia in your local Subway.

Popular Subway Secret Menu Items

Now that we understand the concept, let’s explore some of the most popular secret menu sandwiches that Subway enthusiasts swear by.

Remember, availability may vary by location, so it’s always a good idea to check with your local Subway staff before getting your hopes up for a particular creation.

The Carnivore

For meat lovers, The Carnivore is the ultimate indulgence. This protein-packed sandwich combines multiple meat options on a single sub.

Typically, it includes ham, turkey, roast beef, and bacon, but you can customize it to your liking. To order, simply ask for your preferred bread and request all the meats you desire.

Pizza Sub

Craving pizza but want the convenience of a sandwich? The Pizza Sub is your answer.

This tasty creation starts with a toasted sub roll, then adds marinara sauce, pepperoni, and a generous helping of melted mozzarella cheese. Some variations include additional toppings like green peppers or onions for extra flavor.

The Wing Effect

Bring the flavors of your favorite wing joint to Subway with The Wing Effect. This spicy sensation combines chicken strips with buffalo sauce and ranch dressing. For added crunch, consider adding lettuce and tomatoes. It’s like enjoying buffalo wings in sandwich form!

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Transport yourself to a French bistro with the Chicken Cordon Bleu sandwich. This elegant option combines chicken breast, ham, and Swiss cheese.

Ask for it toasted to achieve that perfect melty consistency. For an extra touch of authenticity, request a drizzle of honey mustard sauce.

The Feast

Can’t decide which meats to choose? Go for The Feast! This monster of a sandwich includes almost every meat option available at Subway.

We’re talking turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, pepperoni, and bacon – all piled high on your choice of bread. It’s not for the faint of heart (or small appetites)!

Eggs Florentine

Who says Subway is just for lunch and dinner? The Eggs Florentine brings breakfast flavors to your sandwich.

This morning-inspired creation combines scrambled eggs, spinach, and cheese on your choice of bread. It’s a great option for those looking for a hearty breakfast on the go.

The Big Philly Cheesesteak

Take the classic Philly Cheesesteak and supersize it with The Big Philly Cheesesteak. This beefed-up version includes extra steak, double cheese, and all your favorite veggies. Ask for it toasted to get that authentic Philly feel.

Can I customize a Subway secret menu item?

Yes, you can customize any Subway Secret Menu item. Just tell the sandwich artist what you would like to add or remove from the sandwich.

For example, if you are ordering the Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub, you could ask for it to be toasted, or you could ask for extra Swiss cheese. You could also ask for the sandwich to be made with a different type of bread such as wheat bread or flatbread.

Subway sandwich artists are very accommodating so don’t be afraid to experiment and create your own unique sub.

How to Order from the Secret Menu

Even though Subway doesn’t promote its Secret Menu publicly, you can still indulge in these delightful dishes by following these easy steps:

Do Your Research: Conduct Research Before going to the restaurant, familiarize yourself with the things on the secret menu.
Be Polite and Respectful: Remember that the hidden menu is not commonly recognized, so be respectful and polite while placing your order and asking if the item may be made.
Know the Ingredients: Understanding the Secret Item’s Ingredients will enable you to specify what you desire.
Customize Wisely: Since the items aren’t on the standard menu, some establishments could not have all the required ingredients. Be adaptable and ready to make adjustments based on what is available.
Order with Confidence: Don’t be afraid to place your order; if you do so, you might receive a pleasant surprise.

How to Make Your Own Secret Menu Item

Feeling inspired? Why not create your own secret menu item? Here are some tips to get you started:

Get creative with ingredients: Mix and match proteins, veggies, and sauces to create unique flavor combinations.

Think outside the bun: Consider using a salad bowl or wrap instead of traditional bread.

Draw inspiration from other cuisines: Why not create a Thai-inspired sub with sweet chili sauce and peanuts?

Work with the staff: Build a rapport with your local Subway employees. They might be more willing to accommodate special requests if you’re a regular customer.

Tips for Ordering From the Subway Secret Menu

Here are a few tips for ordering from the Subway secret menu:

  • Be Polite and respectful. Subway sandwich artists are busy People so be sure to be patient and understanding.
  • Be clear about What you want. Don’t be afraid to tell the sandwich artist exactly what you want on your sub.
  • Be prepared for the Sandwich artist to not be familiar with the secret menu item. If the sandwich artist is not familiar with the item be prepared to explain the ingredients to them.
  • Don’t be afraid to experiment. With so many Secret menu items to choose from, there is sure to be Something that everyone will enjoy.

Can I use my Subway coupons on secret menu items?

Yes, you can use your Subway coupons on secret menu items. Subway coupons are valid on all food items that are sold at Subway, regardless of whether they are on the regular menu or the secret menu.

However, there are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Some Subway coupons may have restrictions on the types of food items that they can be used on. For example, a coupon for a free sub may not be valid on secret menu items.
  • Some Subway coupons may have restrictions on the days and times that they can be used. For example, a coupon for a discounted sub may not be valid on weekends or holidays.

It is always best to read the terms and conditions of your Subway coupon before you use it to make sure that it is valid on the secret menu item that you want to order.

Can I order a Subway secret menu item for catering?

While Subway doesn’t officially have a “secret menu,” there are some unofficial custom orders that have gained popularity among customers. However, ordering these for catering might be challenging. Here’s why:

Consistency: Catering orders typically rely on standard menu items to ensure consistency and efficiency.

Staff familiarity: Not all Subway employees may be familiar with unofficial menu items.

Volume: Preparing custom orders for a large group could be time-consuming and potentially disrupt their operations.

Ingredients: Some secret menu items might require ingredients that aren’t typically stocked in large quantities.

Cost: Custom orders may not have set pricing for catering portions.

Subway Hours 

Days Opening Time Closing Time
Monday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Tuesday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Wednesday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Thursday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Friday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM
Sunday 9:00 AM 10:00 PM


The Subway secret menu is a testament to the creativity of sandwich lovers worldwide. It offers a fun way to break out of your ordering routine and discover new flavor combinations.

Remember, the key to enjoying the secret menu is a mix of knowledge, clear communication, and a spirit of adventure.

So, next time you visit Subway, why not step off the beaten path and try something new? Your taste buds will thank you!

FAQs – Subway Secret Menu

What is the Subway Secret Menu?

The Subway Secret Menu is an unofficial collection of custom sandwich combinations and off-menu items that customers can order using Subway’s standard ingredients.

How do I order from Subway’s Secret Menu?

To order from the Secret Menu, simply ask for the specific combination by name or describe the ingredients you want. Be prepared to explain the item, as not all staff may be familiar with Secret Menu items.

What’s the most popular Subway Secret Menu item?

The Pizza Sub is one of the most popular Secret Menu items, consisting of a toasted sub with marinara sauce, pepperoni, and melted mozzarella cheese.

Is the Subway Secret Menu available at all locations?

Availability may vary by location, as Subway restaurants are franchises. It’s best to check with your local Subway to see if they can accommodate Secret Menu requests.

Are Subway Secret Menu items more expensive?

Subway generally prices Secret Menu items similarly to standard menu items with comparable ingredients, though prices can vary.

What’s the Subway Old Cut method?

The Old Cut, a Secret Menu technique, cuts the bread in a V-shape from the top, instead of using the standard side slice. This method allows for more fillings and better ingredient distribution.

Can I create my own Subway Secret Menu item?

Yes! You can create your own Secret Menu item by combining Subway’s standard ingredients in unique ways. If it becomes popular, it might even gain unofficial Secret Menu status.

What’s the Wing Effect on Subway’s Secret Menu?

The Wing Effect is a Secret Menu item that combines chicken strips with buffalo sauce and ranch dressing, mimicking the flavors of buffalo wings in sandwich form.

Are there vegetarian options on Subway’s Secret Menu?

Yes, there are vegetarian Secret Menu options. For example, you can order the “Veggie Patty Parm,” which is a veggie patty with marinara sauce and melted cheese.

Does Subway officially recognize the Secret Menu?

No, Subway doesn’t officially recognize or promote a Secret Menu. Customers created these combinations using standard ingredients.

Leave a Comment